Friday, July 3, 2015

Data archive requirements

Good stuff (new requirements for NASA Planetary Data Archives)

Proposed archives should have the following features:

  1. The Archive shall be managed by someone other than the data provider. (Independence)
  2. The Archive shall be managed for the long-term (25 years at least). (Sustainability)
  3. The Archive shall be accessible to the public (lay and scientific) without preapproval. (Open Accessibility)
  4. The Archive shall ensure that data are searchable. (Searchability)
  5. The Archive shall ensure that data are citable. (Citability)
  6. The Archive shall be considered by its user community as the “standard” archive for the subfield. (Preeminence)
  7. The Archive shall require that data products be submitted in standardized formats and file types. (Standardization)
  8. Archive should conduct independent peer reviews of data to assess usability and completeness of data packages. (Peer Review)
  9. Archive should include documentation for it's holding such as user guides, calibration descriptions, etc. (Documentation)

Monday, June 23, 2014

Interesting read. I never knew that a slight redefinition of the entropy gets rid of negative temperatures:
Not hotter than hot, Nature Physics by Igor Sokolov.

Wednesday, March 19, 2014

The earliest drawings and paintings of Mauna Kea, Hawaii

Originally Posted Sep 29, 2013

The earliest drawings and paintings of Mauna Kea. There is snow on the summit on all but the earliest, which was drawn by Louis Choris in the years immediately following the Mt. Tambora eruption, which affected climate worldwide. However, this is probably a coincidence as writings from early visitors to Hawaii indicate Mauna Kea was free of snow at other times as well.

Tuesday, March 11, 2014

Scientific Works of Bruce C. Murray (1931-2013)

Originally Posted Sep 29, 2013

Every obituary of Professor Bruce Murray that I have come across focuses on his administrative career, so here is one about his seminal scientific contributions.

Murray, together with Caltech colleagues Kenneth Watson and Harrison Brown, predicted that water ice accumulates in permanently cold craters on the Moon. He and his colleagues realized that, unlike other volatiles, H2O can be retained on the Moon by a combination of hopping and trapping of molecules. Molecules hop along ballistic trajectories at thermal speeds until they reach one of the cold traps near the lunar poles. Detailed quantitative studies of this process were published in two papers in 1961. The work received little attention initially; after all the Apollo samples were bone dry. Today it is a main focus of the lunar exploration program. Many lines of evidence suggest that there is indeed water in cold dark craters near the lunar poles. The same theory also applies to Mercury, where ice deposits have been identified.

In 1966, Prof. Murray made a fundamental prediction about water ice on Mars, together with physicist Robert Leigthon, otherwise known as co-author of the Feynman Lectures. Leighton and Murray realized that the presence of water vapor in the martian atmosphere implies that ice can persist just a few centimeters below the surface, where it is protected from daily temperature variations. This study gained traction also only slowly, but was eventually worked out in increasing detail and served as motivation for sending a neutron spectrometer in orbit around Mars, which indeed identified near-surface ice in great abundance. It was also the primary motivation behind the Phoenix Mars Lander, which in 2008 ultimately touched the ice that Leighton and Murray had predicted 42 years earlier.

Murray's scientific contributions are manifold, and, of course, they include major exploration discoveries such as canyon systems on Mars, the cratered surface of Mercury, and the atmospheric circulation of Venus. The two theoretical contributions described above are not only his most cited, but they will continue to be highly relevant for the exploration of the Moon, Mars, and Mercury for many more decades to come.

A few great manuscripts that crossed my desk

Originally Posted Feb 24, 2013

I have refereed way over a hundred scientific papers for various journals. Here are some of those that I found most memorable and impressive:

  • Serina Diniega et al. A new dry hypothesis for the formation of martian linear gullies. Icarus 224, 526-537 (2013).
  • Wei-Jay Ni and Herve Capart. Groundwater drainage and recharge by networks of irregular channels. J. Geophys. Res. F 111, F02014 (2006).
  • Farhang Radjai and Stephane Roux. Turbulentlike fluctuations in quasistatic flow of granular media. Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 064302 (2002).
  • ...

Wednesday, August 5, 2009

A wonderful lesson on error analysis

Originally posted Aug 5, 2009

This column describes how an exceedingly simple mistake in error analysis was exploited in a major paper.

P. Chylek. Uncertainty over weakening circulation. Physics Today, March 2007.